There has been a lot of talk recently about the difference between a mortgage banker and a mortgage broker. This talk is not just from realtors and consumers, but those in the mortgage industry. And if it seems a little confusing at times to the actual loan officer, just imagine what it might seem like to the average realtor or even the consumer.There are 2 main differences with a 3rd that will be explained later on within this post.
A Mortgage broker acts as an intermediary who sources mortgage loans on behalf of individuals or businesses. Traditionally, banks and other lending institutions have distributed their own products. (from Wikipedia)
A mortgage banker is one who originates, sells, and services mortgages in the secondary mortgage market. Using their own funds to close a loan. (from www.investorwords.com)
The diagram below represents a broker or a banker. It says if the borrower goes to a broker, the broker sends it to a wholesale lender before you can get your house. On the other hand, if you go to the banker, they use their own money. There will be some differences in what kinds of bankers there are that will be explained below.



In the diagram above, you have a borrower that can either go to a banker or a broker to buy or refinance their home. Here is part of the problem when someone might talk about a banker. Many of you think of a local bank who has someone that sits at the bank and can help you with your financing needs, hence they can be called a banker. They have checking & savings accounts, CD's, and other banking specialties.These are your local banks, large or small. But many of these banks don't have loan officers that know many of the programs out there or are not usually creative in saving you money. Some larger known banks would be Wachovia, Chase Manhattan, Commerce Bank (on the east coast) and Wells Fargo. These bankers are large, use their own money, and have experienced loan officers just as brokers. And it is true that brokers account for most of the mortgages that are originated. One main reason though is because it's cheaper to operate as a broker, but this doesn't necessarily mean that they are cheaper or better. I'll explain why later.
They type of mortgage banker that I am talking about is one who uses their own money but who can sell to other lenders acting as a broker. This can be also known as a correspondent lender. What this banker can do is use their own money from a warehouse line and hold onto your mortgage for a month until they sell it on the secondary market. You have already been locked in with this lender who can then get a bulk price for volume which allows them to still give you very competitive pricing. And these same bankers have all the programs at their finger tips just as a broker does.
The other issue is that your traditional bankers mentioned above, for the most part, can act as a broker on certain types of deals in order to have access to all types of "less than perfect" credit loans. The reason being is that they don't want to service this type of mortgage because of it's risk, so they will act as a broker.And some actually do service these credit risk loans. Also, those that say a true banker can't give you the best deal, is slightly misleading the general public. Their pricing is just as competitive as the broker and can sometimes can be better depending on their volume. This is called units at which time, the more they do, the more they can drive down pricing for their clients.
Conclusion : In my opinion, the problem that I see is that brokers will make it sound like they are cheaper in both rate and cost because they have hundred's of lenders (wholesalers) that they can sell to.They will sometimes swear up and down about this. And you will have bankers that will swear that you aren't getting the best rate because brokers are a middle man. The funny thing is that the money comes from the same place when all said and done. It's priced through Wall Street in regards to pools of money.
So, what's all the hoopla? Each is vying for your business. Meaning that these are sales tactics at times. If you read this whole thing over and over, what is missed the most? SERVICE - TRUST - KNOWLEDGE - COMMUNICATION This is what you should be looking for and not a bunch of broken promises.
The honest difference? Besides what was mentioned in the last sentence? Brokers don't underwrite their own loans which means that they can't close their own loans. Now, there will be an argument that brokers can get loans done just as quickly because of their relationships with certain companies. Yes, this can be true at times, but is still a negative in my book. I am a banker that sells our loans on the secondary market which does not affect you, the consumer. So I have many lenders that I can sell to just as a broker. Best of both worlds.
Not only do we underwrite our own loans, but we also close them in-house, using are own money. What does this mean? I have more control. I can usually get things done quicker than the average broker because I have someone in-house that underwrites and close these loans. And as stated, I have more control because of what I can approve in-house than a broker relying on an underwriter that is not part of their company. But again, this is my opinion of almost 15 years in this industry.
The people that I would be most afraid of are those that advertise like this. (may it be in writing, over the phone, on the internet, or on their web site/profile page)
- LOWEST RATES...EASIEST TERMS 100% loans also available. Close in 7 days or less. N0 out of
pocket expense. Pre-Approval guaranteed in 24 HOURS. CALL NOW!!!
So, what is wrong with the above statement? Anyone that states lowest rates and other phrases such as ZERO expenses/costs and or the word guarantee. These are sales pitches. Again, this is what you want from your lender. SERVICE - TRUST - KNOWLEDGE - COMMUNICATION
One last thing that you want to make sure your lender can handle is conventional, FHA, VA, and subprime types of loans. You don't want to be on the short end of the stick, depriving you of every program out there, depending on your financing needs.